Kay’s Cuts: Just the facts please
Steve Kay, Cattle Buyers’ Weekly
via Beef Central (AU) - 12/01/2022
A monthly column written for Beef Central by US meat and livestock industry commentator Steve Kay, publisher of US Cattle Buyers’ Weekly
Misinformation and even disinformation is not new to the United States beef industry.
It’s fascinating, though, how the onset and impact of the coronavirus pandemic amplified the claims of critics of the industry, especially of the beef processing sector. Similar claims may be evident in Australia.
Most critics claim the “Big Four” US packers control more than 80 percent of the US beef supply and have increased their market share at the expense of producers. They also have claimed in the past year that the pandemic proved the industry does not have enough slaughter capacity. They argue that this will be rectified with the addition of new processing plants and the expansion of others.
If only any of this was correct.
The facts tell another story. The Big Four US packers (Tyson Foods, JBS USA, Cargill and National Beef Packing) do have an 81.7pc share of grainfed steer and heifer slaughter (my estimate*) for their 2020 share).
But steers and heifers do not account for all beef produced in the US. Cow and bull slaughter must be added. The result is that the four have a 69.8pc share of total commercial cattle slaughter, a far cry from +80pc.
That the market share of the major US packers keeps increasing is also a fallacy. Their share in 2020 declined from 2019.
The top three packers had a 2020 market share of total commercial cattle slaughter of 58.8pc, down from 60.4pc in 2019. Their share of steer and heifer slaughter declined to 67.7pc from 68.1pc in 2019. The top five packers’ share of commercial slaughter in 2020 was 75.7pc versus 76.1pc in 2019. Their share of steer and heifer slaughter was 84.3pc versus 83.8pc in 2019.
Meanwhile, daily slaughter capacity at the nation’s 30 largest beef processors increased slightly in 2021 from a year earlier. The Top 30 packers currently have the capacity to process 127,915 head per day in 55 plants. That’s 1820 head more than the total capacity of 126,095 head a year ago in 54 plants. The top five packers have a combined capacity of 97,500 head per day in 27 plants, the same as a year ago.
Add the capacity of another 38 small plants and you arrive at a US industry-wide maximum capacity of just over 133,000 head per days. Let’s assume all plants run at 95pc of capacity. That’s a daily slaughter total of 126,350 head. Yet there was scarcely a day in 2021 that the U&S daily kill exceeded 122,000 head. As I have written previously in this column, capacity is not the issue. A shortage of labor is.
Meanwhile, there are eight proposed projects that would expand US slaughter capacity by 9100 head per day...